A 9–16-year Kentucky and Indiana blend finished in French oak. Deep dark fruit, mature oak, and a remarkably persistent spice-driven finish make this one memorable pour.
Stats
- Type: Finished Blended Bourbon
- Age: 9-16 year
- Proof: 125.2 (62.6% ABV)
- Mashbills: Undisclosed
- Origin: Undisclosed distilleries — Kentucky & Indiana
- Additional Aging: Provenance/Reveries — Middleburg, Virginia
- Finish: French oak
- Barrel: MOC-18
- Barrel Picker: Cask Collective (NOVA Whiskey Club)
- Barrels Released: 24
- Release: Limited release, single barrel
- MSRP: $159.99 / 750 mL (only available currently via bundle, cheapest is $210 via Dram Cellars)
Tasting Notes
- Nose: Mature oak leads the way, accompanied by cake frosting, blackberry, toffee, and mocha. There’s an almost old-fashioned cinnamon donut quality alongside a subtle cola note, bringing to mind some of the older Kentucky profiles I’ve encountered from Heaven Hill and Barton.
- Palate: Oily and robust, with an immediate herbal spice and a considerable amount of heat. Toffee and espresso provide a brief moment of sweetness before the barrel spice takes over, delivering a surprisingly aggressive and full-bodied experience.
- Finish: The barrel spice carries exceptionally long, bringing clove, tobacco, drying leather, and oak. What makes this particularly memorable is the lingering undercurrent of blueberry, blackberry, and leather, with just a hint of mint chocolate ice cream adding another unexpected layer.

Some bottles make an impression because of their age, others because of their blending, and a few because everything comes together in a way that’s difficult to replicate. Reveries Murder of Crows manages to make a case for all three. This 125.2-proof blend of 9–16-year Kentucky and Indiana bourbon brings together mature oak, deep sweetness, and a French oak finish that adds another layer of complexity without simply overwhelming what’s already there.
It’s also a bottle with a little personal history for me. MOC18 was the final barrel pick I led as part of NOVA Whiskey Club and its barrel-picking arm, Cask Collective. That connection certainly gives me a personal investment in the bottle, but having tasted several Murder of Crows releases before and since, I’ve continued to be impressed by the consistency of the work behind them. There’s a lot to unpack here, particularly once the whiskey moves beyond its initial sweetness.


Presentation
Reveries continues to deliver some of my favorite bottle designs. There’s a minimalistic, premium quality to the presentation, with the Edgar Allan Poe-inspired imagery carrying through the Murder of Crows name and artwork. Each release seems to have its own visual identity, almost like a different logo, without losing the consistency of the overall brand.
The metallic gloss and shimmer are tastefully executed, adding just enough visual interest without becoming excessive. I also appreciate the simple, tall bottle silhouette. Rather than relying on an extravagant shape to command attention, the design brings the focus back to what’s inside.
Distinctiveness
A case of getting what you would hope for from a well-executed, well-aged bourbon blend, but with an additional dimension that makes it stand out.
The Kentucky and Indiana whiskey provides a mature foundation, while the French oak finishing brings deeper sweetness, dark fruit, additional barrel spice, and a more robust mouthfeel. I’ve encountered plenty of French oak-finished bourbons that either miss the mark or allow the finishing influence to become too dominant. That’s not the case here.
What really separates this bottle is the way those characteristics evolve. There’s a lovely balance on the nose, a brief appearance of sweetness across the middle of the palate, and then a powerful transition into wood and spice. The finish is particularly distinctive, with dark berries and leather lingering well after the initial heat has subsided.

“…a distinctive, memorable release that delivers an experience well beyond simply putting an impressive age statement on the label.”
Transparency
There’s room for improvement here, particularly because the blend itself is such an important part of the bottle’s appeal.
We know we’re getting a blend of 9–16-year bourbon from Kentucky and Indiana, finished in French oak. That’s a good starting point, but I’d love to see more detail about the individual components. Specific age percentages, distillery origins, mashbills, and the duration of the French oak finishing would all help paint a more complete picture.
Those details matter even more at this price point, where the blending and finishing are central to the value proposition. I’d welcome additional information from Reveries, particularly about how the different components were selected and brought together.
For additional background on the people and philosophy behind these releases, check out my [one-on-one with Jay West] where we got into sourcing, blending, and the thinking behind the whiskey.

Value
At $159.99, Murder of Crows is unquestionably a premium-priced bourbon. Looking at the age range alone, I’d put a reasonable value somewhere around $110–$130, depending on the actual proportions of the older and younger components.
The additional value comes from the blending and finishing. Bringing together 24 barrels of mature Kentucky and Indiana bourbon and executing a French oak finish that adds meaningful complexity isn’t an insignificant undertaking. More importantly, the quality in the glass supports much of that premium.
Reveries releases frequently sit toward the higher end of the market, but they also have a track record of delivering on taste and quality. I’d still like to see a little more transparency to fully justify the asking price, but this is one of those bottles where the experience makes a compelling argument.

Buy if:
- You appreciate mature, well-aged bourbon with plenty of oak character.
- You enjoy French oak finishing that adds complexity rather than simply overwhelming the whiskey.
- You gravitate toward dark fruit, leather, tobacco, and robust barrel spice.
- You’re willing to pay a premium for thoughtful blending and distinctive whiskey.
Skip if:
- You prefer softer, sweeter bourbons with less aggressive oak.
- High-proof whiskey with significant heat and spice isn’t your preference.
- You expect detailed mashbill, distillery, and component-age transparency.
- Your budget puts a firm ceiling below $160 for a bourbon.

Verdict
Wow. What a wild pour. Murder of Crows is one of those bottles that reminds me why blending and finishing can be so fascinating when they’re done well. You’re getting 9–16-year bourbon, so some mature Kentucky characteristics are to be expected. But the French oak takes those deeper notes of cola, dark fruit, and mature wood and pushes them into another dimension, adding a substantial layer of barrel spice and richness along the way.
The nose is particularly inviting, offering a little bit of everything while maintaining an impressive balance. The palate takes a more aggressive turn. Sweetness makes a brief appearance before the oak and spice dominate, bringing considerable heat and a finish that lingers as long as almost anything I’ve tasted this year. But the best part might be what happens after that initial intensity. As you breathe out, a deeper layer of blueberry, blackberry, leather, and tobacco settles onto the back of the palate. It’s almost like the lingering overtones of a piece of music, still there after the main notes have faded. I’d genuinely love to see the individual mashbills and percentages behind this blend, because the spice profile makes me wonder whether there’s a particularly high-rye component at work.
I’ll acknowledge my personal connection here: this was the last barrel pick I led with NOVA Whiskey Club and Cask Collective, so there’s naturally some added investment on my end. That said, the other Murder of Crows releases I’ve tasted, both before and since, have consistently demonstrated the quality of Jay West’s blending and finishing work. At $159.99, it’s not an inexpensive bottle, and the lack of component-level transparency leaves something to be desired. But the whiskey itself is exceptional. This is a distinctive, memorable release that delivers an experience well beyond simply putting an impressive age statement on the label.

Bourbon Bishop Bottom Line:
A remarkably complex French oak-finished blend that pairs mature Kentucky bourbon character with explosive barrel spice and one of the most memorable dark-fruit finishes I’ve encountered this year.
For those who prefer numbers, here’s the full score breakdown:
- Nose: 6.25 / 7
- Palate: 6.5 / 7
- Finish: 6.75 / 7
- Presentation: 5.5 / 7
- Distinctiveness: 6.25 / 7
- Transparency: 4 / 7
- Value: 6 / 7
Bourbon Bishop Rating: 5.89 / 7 – Divine
Top-shelf. Must-buy for fans of the style.
| Score | Descriptor | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 0–1 | Hell No | Drain pour. Seriously undrinkable. |
| 1.1–2 | Purgatory | Bad, but could be worse. Only in extreme cases. |
| 2.1–3 | Only Earthly | Just okay. Best used as a mixer. |
| 3.1–4 | Bliss | Passable to Good sipper. Works well in cocktails. |
| 4.1–5 | Angelic | Good to great. Often high value for the price. |
| 5.1–6 | Divine | Top-shelf. Must-buy for fans of the style. |
| 6.1–7 | Holy Heaven | Out-of-this-world. A true unicorn. |
Disclosure: This bottle is from the author’s private collection. All opinions are my own.
About Reveries
Reveries is the whiskey venture of Jay West, better known to many in the bourbon community as t8ke, a respected whiskey enthusiast, blender, and founder of the Provenance Whiskey project. Built around a thoughtful approach to sourcing, blending, and finishing, Reveries focuses on bringing together distinctive barrels to create expressions with their own character and identity. Rather than relying solely on age or proof to make an impression, the emphasis is on what happens when quality whiskey and intentional blending come together.
That philosophy carries through the brand’s releases, which often showcase well-aged American whiskey alongside carefully considered finishing techniques. There’s a particular attention to balance, complexity, and the character of the individual components, with each release offering a glimpse into the decisions behind the blend. For those interested in the people and philosophy behind the bottles, my one-on-one conversation with Jay West offers a closer look at his approach to whiskey, blending, and the Provenance and Reveries projects.


Related Articles
Explore Provenance with Jay West and discover the philosophy behind curated whiskey, Reveries single barrels, slow proofing, experimental finishes, and the Bottle Your Own experience.
I went into my Barrel King whiskey selection expecting to pick a single barrel. Instead, four very different bourbons and ryes (including a 9 year O.Z. Tyler) became The Bourbon Bishop Blend. See how it came together.
Extinct Spirits Extinction Event No. 1: The Dodo Bird is a 114.2-proof, nearly 10-year-old Kentucky bourbon featuring rich maple, dark fruit, mature oak, and an intriguing smoky edge. A distinctive limited release worth serious attention.
Dark Arts Sherry Garcia Vol. 3 is an 8.5-year MGP bourbon finished in Oloroso sherry casks. Explore tasting notes, value, and our verdict.
Redwood Empire The Hyperion blends bourbon, rye, wheat whiskey and American single malt aged 7–14 years. Explore tasting notes, transparency, value and our verdict on this $99, 110-proof release.
I went into my Barrel King whiskey selection expecting to pick a single barrel. Instead, four very different bourbons and ryes (including a 9 year O.Z. Tyler) became The Bourbon Bishop Blend. See how it came together.
Shortbarrel Cigar Batch #4 blends dark cherry, fig, chocolate, leather and lingering rye spice in a complex, approachable American whiskey.
Angel’s Envy Stout and Amburana Finished blends stout-barrel chocolate and cherry with warming cinnamon, ginger, and a lingering Mexican hot chocolate finish.









