Hooten & Young — Gothic Serpent 7-Year Rye Whiskey + RTBA Cigar Pairing Review

Hooten Young's Gothic Serpent Rye sits open with a freshly poured glass with one large ice cube and paired cigar against on top of Jack Carr books

A purpose-built rye that finds its stride not in isolation, but in intentional pairing — where whiskey and cigar begin to speak the same language.


Stats

  • Age: 7 year
  • Proof: 93 (46.5% ABV)
  • Mashbill: 95% Rye│ 5% Malted Barley
  • Origin: Ross & Squibb (MGP) — Lawrenceburg, Indiana
  • Finish: Straight
  • Release: Wide release
  • MSRP: $60.99 (Hooten Young)

Tasting Notes

  • Nose: The nose opens with apple butter, caramelized pear, vanilla cream, and cinnamon sugar, supported by a familiar layer of MGP oak. A subtle deeper sweetness develops with time in the glass, creating a balanced combination of fruit, confectionery notes, and gentle baking spice.
  • Palate: A moderately thin mouthfeel carries notes of light caramel, vanilla cream, grapefruit peel, and soft baking spice. While the profile remains approachable and well-balanced, the mid-palate feels intentionally restrained, serving more as a foundation than a showcase.
  • Finish: The finish transitions from lingering sweetness into tobacco leaf, peppery rye spice, and caramelized stone fruit, particularly apricot and peach. Herbal undertones emerge alongside the growing spice, creating the whiskey’s most engaging and memorable stage.

The Hooten & Young 7-Year Rye Whiskey is a 95% rye / 5% barley mashbill distilled in Lawrenceburg, Indiana and bottled at 93 proof. Aged for 7 years and built on a familiar MGP/Ross & Squibb backbone, it leans into candied fruit sweetness, baking spice, and soft oak structure without trying to reinvent the category.

What makes this release distinct is not radical deviation, but intention. This is a whiskey designed with pairing in mind — particularly cigars — and it becomes most compelling when evaluated through that lens.

Notably, this expression also earned a Double Gold at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, reinforcing its technical execution even if the profile remains grounded in familiarity.

Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye lying against Operator hat
Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye lying against Operator hat

Distinctiveness

At its core, this sits just slightly above your standard 95/5 MGP rye profile — not dramatically different, but not trying to be.

The familiarity is not a flaw. In fact, it becomes the foundation. On its own, it is a well-executed, slightly restrained rye. The real shift happens when it’s reframed through pairing — especially with a cigar, where the whiskey’s fruit, spice, and light oak structure begin to feel more purposeful.

Author’s Note: Presentation section excluded due to being a sample bottle.

Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye by the pool
Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye & RTBA cigar by the pool

Transparency

Based on available information, this is openly sourced from MGP/Ross & Squibb in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, which aligns with its sensory profile.

Label specifics on the sample are not fully confirmed (sample only provided with no back label), but the provided production details are consistent with what is being presented: a 7-year aged, 95/5 rye at 93 proof.

Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye close-up of label
Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye close-up of label

A purpose-built rye that finds its stride not in isolation, but in intentional pairing

Value

At approximately $60.99, this sits in a fair range for a 7-year MGP rye, especially at a lower proof that prioritizes approachability over intensity.

Where value increases meaningfully is in its intentional pairing design. This is not just a standalone pour — it is positioned as part of a curated experience with cigars, and that added layer of utility elevates its proposition beyond the bottle itself.

Hooten Young's Gothic Serpent Rye being opened
Hooten Young’s Gothic Serpent Rye being opened (Image: Hooten Young)

RTBA Cigar Pairing Experience (Integrated Tasting Lens)

When paired with the RTBA cigar (Toro, Ecuador Habano wrapper, Nicaragua binder and filler), the whiskey undergoes a noticeable transformation.

The cigar opens with brown bread, toffee, and subtle cocoa, evolving into espresso and deeper cacao bitterness as it develops. Medium-bodied, but rich in sweet and roasted tones.

When combined, the whiskey suddenly feels more complete and more mature. The rye’s fruit notes — especially pear, apricot, and citrus peel — expand and deepen rather than sit on top of the cigar. Meanwhile, the cigar pulls out hidden structure in the whiskey, amplifying its spice and caramel tones.

The result is a rare moment where both components feel designed to elevate each other rather than compete. The pairing is not subtle — it is clearly intentional — and it works.

Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye and RTBA cigar being enjoyed in hot tub
Hooten Young Gothic Serpent Rye and RTBA cigar being enjoyed in hot tub

Buy if:

  • You enjoy MGP-based 95/5 rye profiles with familiar structure
  • You appreciate whiskeys designed specifically for cigar pairing
  • You value a bottle that improves significantly in a curated experience context
  • You want a mid-proof, 7-year rye with soft fruit and spice balance

Skip if:

  • You’re looking for a bold or heavily differentiated rye profile
  • You prefer high-proof intensity or heavy oak extraction
  • You want a whiskey that stands entirely on its own without context or pairing
  • You dislike MGP-driven rye character profiles
Hooten Young RTBA Cigar by fire
Hooten Young RTBA Cigar by fire

Verdict

The Hooten & Young 7-Year Rye is a solid, approachable expression that doesn’t try to reinvent the well-established 95/5 MGP rye formula. On its own, it delivers pleasant fruit, sweetness, and spice with a particularly enjoyable finish, though the palate can feel somewhat reserved compared to the more expressive nose and finish.

What separates this bottle from countless other sourced ryes is the intent behind it. Pairing it with the RTBA cigar transformed the experience, amplifying the whiskey’s fruit character, adding perceived age and depth, and creating a synergy that made both products more enjoyable than either would be independently. While I wouldn’t place it among the most distinctive rye releases on the market, I came away appreciating that Hooten & Young appears to know exactly what this whiskey is meant to be: a purpose-built companion pour designed to elevate a cigar experience.

For those who prefer numbers, here’s the full score breakdown:

Bourbon Bishop Rating: 4.13 / 7 – Angelic

Good to great. Often high value for the price.

ScoreDescriptorNotes
0–1Hell NoDrain pour. Seriously undrinkable.
1.1–2PurgatoryBad, but could be worse. Only in extreme cases.
2.1–3Only EarthlyJust okay. Best used as a mixer.
3.1–4BlissPassable to Good sipper. Works well in cocktails.
4.1–5AngelicGood to great. Often high value for the price.
5.1–6DivineTop-shelf. Must-buy for fans of the style.
6.1–7Holy HeavenOut-of-this-world. A true unicorn.

Disclosure: This sample was provided to me free of charge for review. All opinions are my own.

About Hooten Young

Founded by retired U.S. Army Master Sergeant Norm Hooten, one of the soldiers portrayed in Black Hawk Down, Hooten Young was built around a simple idea: that exceptional whiskey and cigars can help preserve stories worth remembering. Inspired by the camaraderie forged around campfires and during military service, the veteran-owned company embraces the mantra Made to Remember®, honoring those who have served and sacrificed.

That commitment extends beyond the products themselves. Hooten Young actively supports veteran-focused and military-service organizations while striving to produce whiskey and cigars that reflect the same standards of excellence expected of those who wear the uniform. Whether through a thoughtfully crafted pour or a carefully blended cigar, the brand aims to create experiences that celebrate service, remembrance, and shared connection.

Hooten Young cigar is lit
Hooten Young cigar is lit (Image: Hooten Young)
Hooten Young's Gothic Serpent Rye pours into a waiting rocks glass
Hooten Young’s Gothic Serpent Rye pours into a waiting rocks glass (Image: Hooten Young)

Related Articles

Hooten Young's Gothic Serpent Rye won Double Gold at the 2026 SFWSC

Hooten Young’s Operation Gothic Serpent Rye Whiskey has earned Double Gold at the 2026 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. The 7-year-old rye pays tribute to the 19 Americans lost during the Battle of Mogadishu and was unanimously awarded Gold by every judge.

Read More →

Found North Cask Strength Batch 012 amongst green tree leaves (close)

Found North Batch 012 delivers an unusually creamy and marshmallow-forward take on well-aged Canadian whisky, balancing heavy toast, rye spice, and refined tannins with one of the most distinctive mouthfeels in recent memory.

Read More →

Dark Arts Empyrean Vol. 2

Dark Arts Empyrean Vol. 2 blends separately finished white and red port MGP bourbons into a jammy, smoky, tannic pour that evolves nicely over time, even if it lacks the impact of previous Blue Label releases.

Read More →

H.K. Young "The Bourbon Bishop x Bourbon Papi" Toasted Wheated Bourbon Single Barrel

A 7-year, 129.6 proof HKY toasted wheated private barrel selected by Ethan Pope (@thebourbonbishop) and Pierre Bernal (@pierrebernal_). Dessert-forward with structure, defined by a long, spice-driven finish.

Read More →

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *